EST. JOHNSTOWN

Small-batch gelato. Real ingredients. Zero pretense.

We don't do frozen mass production. Every batch at I Scream is churned fresh daily using local dairy and seasonal fruit—because your Tuesday deserves the same quality as your Saturday.

View Today's Flavors Find Our Shop

12+ Daily Flavors

100% Local Dairy

Artisan gelato displayed in copper containers

The Philosophy

We make ice cream the way your grandmother insisted: slowly, carefully, and with actual cream.

Most commercial ice cream is overrun with air and stabilizers. Ours is dense, silky, and packed with flavor because we refuse to cut corners. We source eggs from local farms, chocolate from single-origin distributors, and fruit from Pennsylvania orchards when it's in season.

Located on Ohio Street, we've been serving Johnstown with the same dedication since day one. Whether you're grabbing a single scoop to go or settling in for a cold brew and a slice of tiramisu, we treat every visit like a conversation with a friend.

Churned in small batches daily
No artificial colors or preservatives
Vegan and gluten-free options available

The Menu

What's Churning Today

Our rotating selection changes with the seasons. These are the crowd favorites that keep Johnstown coming back.

Midnight Espresso

Double-shot espresso folded into dark chocolate base. For the serious caffeine lovers.

Vanilla Bean

Madagascar vanilla beans in fresh cream. Simple, classic, and impossible to get wrong.

Strawberry Rhubarb

Local strawberries meet tart rhubarb. A Pennsylvania classic that screams summer.

Mint Chocolate Chip

House-made mint extract with dark chocolate shards. Not your freezer-aisle version.

Hazelnut Praline

Toasted hazelnuts caramelized to perfection, creating a nutty, crunchy swirl.

Salted Caramel

Buttery caramel with Maldon sea salt. Sweet, salty, and dangerously smooth.

See Full Menu In-Store Ask about our daily special and rotating seasonal flavors.

More Than Gelato

The Café Experience

I Scream isn't just about the scoop. Our café counter serves expertly pulled espressos, rich cold brews, and handcrafted shakes that pair perfectly with our gelato.

Whether you need a morning pick-me-up or an afternoon treat, our space is designed for lingering. Grab a seat, people-watch on Ohio Street, and let us take care of the rest.

☕
                                Specialty Coffee
                                Premium beans, expertly pulled
                            

🥤
                                Shakes & Floats
                                Classic combinations, elevated
                            

🍰
                                Dessert Pairings
                                House-baked goods daily
                            

Cozy café interior with customers enjoying coffee

Find Us

Come Say Hello

We're right on Ohio Street, easy to find and impossible to forget. Stop by anytime during our opening hours.

Address 324 Ohio St
Johnstown, PA 15902

Phone (181) 691-4156

Email iscreamicecream324@gmail.com

Hours Mon–Sat: 11am – 9pm
Sunday: 12pm – 8pm

Street view of Johnstown Ohio Street area

Open in Google Maps